Thursday, April 22, 2010

Is Bipolar genes "selfish"?

Heya

I must honestly say that I’ve been trying to avoid this writing post. My mother reckons that my argument is abit ambitious and somewhat unclear. I agree, “The selfish gene” was not such an easy book to read. I suppose if I was reading for pleasure or just to broaden my knowledge it would have been fine; seeing as I do have some biological background. My idea, however, was to review this book within the context of Bipolar as a genetically inherited disease.



This is not easy for a couple of reasons: 1) The author warns that the theory cannot /shouldn’t be extrapolated to humans; 2) Bipolar is not carried on one gene but many (so called ‘gene complex’); 3) Environmental factors play a huge role in whether it is expressed or not. So these are the challenges, and I’ve given up one to many times which means I’ll give it a shot. This may get complicated so feel free to comment.

I think the essence of what Dawkins is trying to say is that evolution acts upon genes instead of individuals (You, me, dogs, and horses) or populations (e.g. pack of wolves, school of fish). I think this makes sense because genes are the replication mechanism. This means that the environment will select products of replication (i.e. of any living organism) that work. Hence the term “natural selection” and “survival of the fittest”. Fittest meaning ability to produce enough healthy offspring.

So why then would nature act on the human gene to produce a genetic mutation such as Bipolar? And if it is such a harmful gene causing a debilitating disorder, why is it still so prevalent (and increasing)? Apparently the answer is to be found in our diets. In his book, “the madness of Adam and eve”, biochemist David Horrobin argues that schizophrenia and other forms of functional psychoses (i.e. including bipolar), were caused by abnormalities in lipid chemistry due to diet change at a time when mankind was diverging from apes and hominids. A mouthful, I know. In simple terms this means that there was a change in the fat content of our brain cells. This resulted in more careful control of electric signals allowing the brain to make more complex connections within our cortexes.

It follows that schizophrenia, bipolar, autism, and the like were extreme occurrences of this process. Apparently the emergence of this “functional psychoses” was related to increased creativity. If not in the individuals themselves, then close relatives (e.g. Nobel Prize winner Albert Einstein had a Schizophrenic son). According to Horrobin it was evolutionary pressures that triggered genetic changes in our brain cells, “allowing us to make unexpected links with different events, an ability that lifted our species to a new intellectual plane”.

So the reasons why these genes are still so prevalent are complex. It is important to note that bipolar sufferers usually express symptoms only during and after adolescence, allowing time for procreation. Also, those with milder symptoms or more conducive environments are in many cases top achievers and highly successful allowing more opportunity for procreation. Bipolar mania is often characterized by hypersexuality where sufferers could partake in risky and reckless sexual behaviour due to increased sex drive.

In closing, the environment has triggered the mutation of abnormal genes and natural selection sometimes runs with the idea depending on whether environmental conditions are conducive. Extreme cases of mental illness are eliminated and milder cases tend to prosper at the expense of carrying the replicators into the future. In this way the gene keeps going into and out of generations.....selfish?

5 comments:

  1. I don't think your argument is unclear, however not having read the book your analysis is pretty much all I have to go on.

    Anyhoot, let's flow with your hypothesis for a minute - you've previously said that the symptoms of BiP are many and varied, and they may manifest at different times or more specifically under different conditions depending on internal and external factors. Does that not indicate a completely "random" gene as opposed to a calculating and selective one as described above?

    On another point entirely - I'm starting to think the cure for the human condition consists of a proper diet, enough exercise and sleep and more rigorous mental discipline (to curb excesses) - bringing our bodies up to speed in order to handle the 'higher intellectual plane' we're supposedly on instead of the currently prevailing descent into disease and depravity (no disrespect intended). Your blog certainly promotes this - intended or no? regardless, well done, please continue!

    ReplyDelete
  2. A very interesting question McG. The "symptoms" resulting from having the gene is varied and random. "Calculating and selective"? This is a very important topic covered by Dawkins and it relates to our anthropogenic view of the world...Genes dont have a conciousness (although it may appear that way). Natural selection is the random and selective force. Hope this makes some sense.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Interesting Read and well written my Brilliant friend.

    The simple answer to this theory is... Is God! His creation of mankind is too awesome man and Science will never understand!

    All we can do is seek God - And hope he share a few secrets with us :-)

    Ray

    ReplyDelete
  4. Are you as a Christian allowed to read Dawkins? ;-)

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6mmskXXetcg

    ReplyDelete
  5. Ray and Pascal: You guys are on opposite sides of the spectrum; One atheist the other christian? Interesting. My next blog will speak to both of you...

    ReplyDelete